Stability of Leapfrogging Vortex Pairs: A Semi-analytic Approach


We investigate the stability of a one-parameter family of periodic solutions of the four-vortex problem known as leapfrogging orbits. These solutions, which consists of two pairs of identical yet oppositely-signed vortices, were known to W. Gröbli (1877) and A. E. H. Love (1883), and can be parameterized by a dimensionless parameter $\alpha$ related to the geometry of the initial configuration. Simulations by Acheson (2000) and numerical Floquet analysis by Tophøj and Aref (2012) both indicate, to many digits, that the bifurcation occurs when $\alpha=\phi^{-2}$, where $\phi$ is the golden ratio. This study aims to explain the origin of this remarkable value. Using a trick from the gravitational two-body problem, we change variables to render the Floquet problem in an explicit form that is more amenable to analysis. We then implement G. W. Hill’s method of harmonic balance to high order using computer algebra to construct a rapidly-converging sequence of asymptotic approximations to the bifurcation value, confirming the value found earlier.

Physical Review Fluids


The matrix in Eq. (19) should read $$\small{\left.A_{h}(\theta)\right\rvert_{h=\frac18}= \begin{pmatrix} -\frac{4 \sin {2\theta}}{\sqrt{8 \cos {2\theta}+17}} & \frac{8 \cos ^2{2\theta}-12 \cos {2\theta}+3 \sqrt{8 \cos {2\theta}+17}-11}{2 (1-\cos {2\theta}) \sqrt{8 \cos {2\theta}+17}} \\ \frac{-8 \cos^2{2\theta}-4 \cos {2\theta}-\sqrt{8 \cos {2\theta}+17}+7}{2 (\cos {2\theta}+1) \sqrt{8 \cos {2\theta}+17}} & \frac{4 \sin{2 \theta}}{\sqrt{8 \cos {2\theta}+17}} \end{pmatrix} } $$ This is an isolated error in the writing and does not effect any of the mathematics in the paper.


In the published paper, we show that if the differential equation $$ \frac{{\rm d}}{{\rm d}\theta} \begin{pmatrix} \xi_- \\ \eta_+ \end{pmatrix} = A_h(\theta) \begin{pmatrix} \xi_- \\ \eta_+ \end{pmatrix} $$ has a periodic orbit at $h=\frac18$ of period $\pi$, then the leapfrogging orbit bifurcates at $h=\frac18$. We tried using Mathematica to solve this equation exactly but it failed to return a closed form solution. Therefore in the paper we used high-precision numerics and a high-order perturbation expansion to give strong evidence that the solution with initial condition $(1,0)$ is indeed periodic.

In the summer of 2020 we posted a question to the website MathOverflow asking if anyone could find an exact solution to this equation. Almost immediately, we received the solution from Robert Israel, who found the answer using Maple: $$ \begin{aligned} \xi_- (\theta)&= \phantom{-}\frac{1}{20}\left( 1+4 \cos 2\theta+3\sqrt{17+8 \cos 2\theta} \right) \\ \eta_+(\theta)&= -\frac{\tan\theta}{20}\left( 1+4 \cos 2\theta+\sqrt{17+8 \cos 2\theta} \right) . \end{aligned} $$ Thus, without recourse to perturbation theory or numerics, this exact solution proves the theorem.

Brandon Behring
Brandon Behring
Data Scientist, Prudential Insurance

Brandon defended his dissertation on leapfrogging point vortices in August 2020 He spent about a year as a postdoc in the Dynamical Systems Laboratory at the NYU Tandon School of NYU. He is now a data scientist at Prudential Insurance, and has a very cute baby girl.

Roy Goodman
Roy Goodman
Associate Professor, Department of Mathematical Sciences

My research interests include dynamical systems and nonlinear waves, vortex dynamics, quantum graphs, and network inference